Midland States Bancorp, Inc. (MSBI): A Top Earnings Yield With Strings Attached
Midland States Bancorp, Inc. | MSBI | Published 11/18/2026
Midland States Bancorp, Inc. is the Effingham, Illinois holding company for Midland States Bank, a community bank founded in 1881 with $6.8 billion in assets and 53 banking centers across Illinois and Missouri (42 and 11, respectively), organized into Northern, Eastern, Southern and St. Louis regions. Beyond commercial and retail banking, it runs a sizable wealth management and trust business with $4.77 billion in assets under administration, a specialty finance group, and a third-party fintech lending program that carries full credit indemnification from its partner. The past two years have been eventful: the company restated its 2022 and 2023 financial statements and filed several reports late, recorded a $154.0 million goodwill impairment in 2025, sold substantially all of its equipment finance portfolio in the fourth quarter of 2025, and promoted a new CFO in May 2026. It also has $115 million of 7.75% fixed-rate reset preferred stock (MSBIP) that resets in September 2027, and in October 2026 it filed a $250 million universal shelf registration.
Midland States runs a securities-heavy, highly leveraged balance sheet: loans are only 62.83% of assets, available-for-sale securities are 27.95%, and assets are 12.83x equity. Above-peer yields on loans and securities and low-cost, nearly brokered-free funding produce a 3.97% net interest margin, above the 3.37%–3.70% peer range, and fee income is nearly double peer levels. After higher operating costs and preferred dividends that take 10.73% of net income, profitability is average, with net income at 1.09% of average assets. Every risk category is unfavorable. Problem loans run about double peer levels while the allowance, net of the credit enhancement asset, sits at the bottom of the peer range. Tangible fair-value common equity is just 5.73% after a 29.40% loan haircut and excluding $110.5 million of preferred stock that resets, likely higher, in 2027. Interest rate swaps leave the bank more liability-sensitive than peers. The 11.88% earnings yield is among the highest in the peer population, but it is exposed to all three risks, and the price does not appear low enough to compensate.
The remainder of this analysis is available to paid subscribers. See the rest of the analysis here: MSBI - Midland States Bancorp, Inc.: Full Analysis